论文标题

测量礼节互动的材料痕迹中的纠缠:史前岩画分布中的优先附着

Measuring entanglement in material traces of ritualized interaction: Preferential attachment in a prehistoric petroglyph distribution

论文作者

Froese, Tom, Gallaga, Emiliano

论文摘要

史前摇滚艺术经常被主要分析为艺术家意图的产物,以创建其感知经历和心理图像的公共表现。但是,这种以表示为中心的方法倾向于忽略大量物质参与的性能。许多形式的岩石艺术都可以从艺术家反复与表面互动(包括先前的痕迹)中构想为痕迹。对于这些艺术家而言,可能更相关的意图是仪式化的互动,例如交流和请愿,这些互动被认为是与据信代理机构进行实质性介导的交易,这些交易被认为可以使环境的特定领域动画。如果是这样,我们可以期望这些图案被强烈聚集在仪式吸引人的领域,而不是在类似画布的表面上均匀分布,从而最大程度地发挥其作为公共代表性的可见性。在这里,我们提出了一种以优先依恋来测试以相互作用为中心的方法的新颖方法,这是网络科学的一个概念,描述了流行者倾向于吸引更多追随者的众所周知的社会现象。我们将这种方法应用于墨西哥奇瓦瓦州的古老地点的案例研究,并发现其岩石分布具有功率定律的形式,这与优惠的附件一致。我们得出的结论是,这种方法可以发展为史前物质参与中仪式过程和产品之间纠缠的量度。

Prehistoric rock art is often analyzed predominantly as the product of artists intentions to create public representations of their perceptual experiences and mental imagery. However, this representation-centered approach tends to overlook the performative role of much material engagement. Many forms of rock art are better conceived of as traces from artists repeated engagement with a surface, including with previous traces. For these artists, a potentially more relevant intention was ritualized interaction, such as communion and petition, which were realized as materially mediated transactions with the agencies that were believed to animate specific areas of the environment. If so, we can expect the motifs to be strongly clustered on ritually attractive areas, rather than to be evenly distributed on canvas-like surfaces that would maximize their visibility as public representations. Here we propose a novel way of testing the interaction-centered approach in terms of preferential attachment, which is a concept from network science that describe the well-known social phenomenon that popular agents tend to attract more followers. We applied this approach to a case study of an archaic site in Chihuahua, Mexico, and found that its petroglyph distribution has the form of a power law, which is consistent with preferential attachment. We conclude that this approach could be developed into a measure of the entanglement between ritual processes and products in prehistoric material engagement.

扫码加入交流群

加入微信交流群

微信交流群二维码

扫码加入学术交流群,获取更多资源