论文标题
在学术背景下的二级研究:系统的映射和调查
Secondary Studies in the Academic Context: A Systematic Mapping and Survey
论文作者
论文摘要
背景:一些研究人员报告了他们在应用二级研究(系统文献评论 - SLR和系统映射-SMS)(SE)方面的经验。但是,仍然缺乏研究在学术背景下进行二级研究的价值的研究。目标:这项研究的主要目标是提供有关在学术背景下使用二级研究的概述。方法:使用了两种经验研究方法。最初,我们进行了SM,以确定有关使用中学研究作为进行SE研究项目的研究方法的可用和相关研究。其次,对64位SE研究人员进行了一项调查,以确定其与执行二级研究以支持其研究项目的价值有关的看法。结果:我们的结果表明,在学术背景下使用二级研究的好处,例如提供文献的概述,并确定有关研究领域的相关研究文献,这些研究领域有助于解释为什么应批准研究项目的赠款和/或在研究项目中做出的支持决策。 SE研究生进行了中学研究的困难是,他们倾向于由团队进行,并且比传统评论需要更多的努力。结论:二级研究对研究生很有价值。由于为开发整个项目提供的好处和贡献,他们应该考虑为其研究项目进行二级研究。但是,经验丰富的主管的建议对于避免偏见至关重要。此外,获取技能可以增加学生从事研究项目的动力,并为学术或工业职业做好准备。
Context: Several researchers have reported their experiences in applying secondary studies (Systematic Literature Reviews - SLRs and Systematic Mappings - SMs) in Software Engineering (SE). However, there is still a lack of studies discussing the value of performing secondary studies in an academic context. Goal: The main goal of this study is to provide an overview on the use of secondary studies in an academic context. Method: Two empirical research methods were used. Initially, we conducted an SM to identify the available and relevant studies on the use of secondary studies as a research methodology for conducting SE research projects. Secondly, a survey was performed with 64 SE researchers to identify their perception related to the value of performing secondary studies to support their research projects. Results: Our results show benefits of using secondary studies in the academic context, such as, providing an overview of the literature as well as identifying relevant research literature on a research area enabling to find reasons to explain why a research project should be approved for a grant and/or supporting decisions made in a research project. Difficulties faced by SE graduate students with secondary studies are that they tend to be conducted by a team and it demands more effort than a traditional review. Conclusions: Secondary studies are valuable to graduate students. They should consider conducting a secondary study for their research project due to the benefits and contributions provided to develop the overall project. However, the advice of an experienced supervisor is essential to avoid bias. In addition, the acquisition of skills can increase student's motivation to pursue their research projects and prepare them for both academic or industrial careers.