论文标题

维基百科自然灾害的不均匀覆盖范围:洪水的情况

Uneven Coverage of Natural Disasters in Wikipedia: the Case of Flood

论文作者

Lorini, Valerio, Rando, Javier, Saez-Trumper, Diego, Castillo, Carlos

论文摘要

非授权数据用于灾难管理提供了机会,有机会访问可能无法通过其他方式获得的及时信息,以及处理几层偏见的挑战。维基百科(Wikipedia)是一家合作的百科全书,其中包括有关许多自然和人为灾难的深入信息,随着危机的发展,其编辑尤其擅长实时添加信息。在这项研究中,我们专注于英文版的Wikipedia,这是迄今为止该百科全书中最全面的版本。维基百科往往会弥补灾难,尤其是那些死亡人数大量的灾难。但是,我们还表明,涵盖富裕国家的事件而不涵盖贫困事件的趋势会渗透到维基百科作为与灾难相关信息的来源。通过大规模进行仔细的自动内容分析,我们展示了Wikipedia洪水的覆盖范围如何偏向富有的,讲英语的国家,尤其是美国和加拿大。我们还注意到,收入最低的国家以及南美国家的洪水的覆盖率大大低于中等收入国家洪水的覆盖范围。这些结果对使用Wikipedia或类似协作媒体平台作为检测紧急情况或收集有价值的信息以进行灾难响应的信息来源具有影响。

The usage of non-authoritative data for disaster management presents the opportunity of accessing timely information that might not be available through other means, as well as the challenge of dealing with several layers of biases. Wikipedia, a collaboratively-produced encyclopedia, includes in-depth information about many natural and human-made disasters, and its editors are particularly good at adding information in real-time as a crisis unfolds. In this study, we focus on the English version of Wikipedia, that is by far the most comprehensive version of this encyclopedia. Wikipedia tends to have good coverage of disasters, particularly those having a large number of fatalities. However, we also show that a tendency to cover events in wealthy countries and not cover events in poorer ones permeates Wikipedia as a source for disaster-related information. By performing careful automatic content analysis at a large scale, we show how the coverage of floods in Wikipedia is skewed towards rich, English-speaking countries, in particular the US and Canada. We also note how coverage of floods in countries with the lowest income, as well as countries in South America, is substantially lower than the coverage of floods in middle-income countries. These results have implications for systems using Wikipedia or similar collaborative media platforms as an information source for detecting emergencies or for gathering valuable information for disaster response.

扫码加入交流群

加入微信交流群

微信交流群二维码

扫码加入学术交流群,获取更多资源